Perfect Title
| # | Champion | Defenses | Date Won | Date Lose | Event Won At | Defeated |
| Baker retires the title feeling it has lost its importance | ||||||
| 20 | Ben Smith (2) | 0 | 1/4/04 | - | Doomsday 2003 | Jack Miller and Id |
| 19 | Jack Miller | 1 | 12/27/03 | 1/4/04 | Battle Grounds | Id |
| 18 | Id | 1 | 12/6/03 | 12/27/03 | Battle Grounds | Ben Smith |
| 17 | Ben Smith | 7 | 8/24/03 | 12/6/03 | Ground Zero 2003 | Kano |
| 16 | Kano | 2 | 7/2/03 | 8/24/03 | FullHouse | Gay Cowboy |
| 15 | Gay Cowboy | 1 | 6/7/03 | 7/2/03 | Battle Grounds | Terrance "T" Williams |
| 14 | Terrance "T" Williams | 1 | 5/11/03 | 6/7/03 | Downfall | Tony Smith |
| 13 | Tony Smith | 1 | 4/26/03 | 5/11/03 | Battle Grounds | Monarch |
| 12 | Monarch | 1 | 4/12/03 | 4/26/03 | Battle Grounds | Bronxx |
| 11 | Bronxx (3) | 1 | 3/22/03 | 4/12/03 | Battle Grounds | Mr. Main Event |
| 10 | Mr. Main Event (3) | 1 | 3/15/03 | 3/22/03 | Battle Grounds | Bronxx and Eclipse |
| 9 | Bronxx (2) | 1 | 3/9/03 | 3/15/03 | HellBound 2003 | Greatest Wrestler Ever |
| 8 | Greatest Wrestler Ever | 2 | 2/26/03 | 3/9/03 | FullHouse | Bronxx |
| 7 | Bronxx | 1 | 2/15/03 | 2/26/03 | Battle Grounds | Annexx, Annaniah and Magdalena |
| 6 | Mr. Main Event (2) | 0 | 2/9/03 | 2/9/03 | Revelations 2003 | Annexx |
| 5 | Annexx | 1 | 1/18/03 | 2/9/03 | Battle Grounds | JBD |
| 4 | JBD | 1 | 1/15/03 | 1/18/03 | FullHouse | Mr. Main Event |
| 3 | Mr. Main Event | 1 | 1/8/03 | 1/15/03 | FullHouse | Fortune |
| 2 | Fortune | 1 | 12/29/02 | 1/8/03 | Doomsday 2002 | Thorn |
| 1 | Thorn | 1 | 12/25/02 | 12/29/02 | FullHouse | Mr. Main Event |